Showing posts with label Cloverfield. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cloverfield. Show all posts

8/2/09

WAR IS NOT HEALTHY FOR CHILDREN OR OTHER LIVING THINGS… But it makes for some profound pop-art

War results in terrible things. In spite of its occasional merit, its arguable inevitability, the solutions and resolutions it can result in, and the possible undesirable outcome which sometimes concludes it, war is a catalyst for provocative, meaningful art. Consider the era of the Vietnam Conflict. Some of history’s greatest films were a product of its disillusion. There is a relevant argument that only art can truly bring the catastrophes of war into tangibility for a culture. Art forces people to confront issues they may otherwise write off as trivial. It forces them to see the other side of an argument they might otherwise never change their position on. Since the terrorist attacks of September 11th, 2001, and the downward spiral the war in Iraq appears to be on, popular film has once again taken on the heart of issues journalism and philosophy sometimes fail to report or comprehend. Films like M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village, Matt Reeves’ Cloverfield, Frank Darabont’s The Mist, and Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Night unflinchingly satirize the issues that endanger our crumbling democracy in the face of combating terror.


Shyamalan’s The Village was doomed to be misunderstood when Touchstone Pictures decided to market the movie as a conventional horror film with a trademark Shyamalan twist. Upon its immediate release, the buzz about The Village morphed from confusion to negativity. Sadly, I hypothesize that a great deal of the American public who bashed the film did not understand what the confusion was: and the confusion was and still is us, the people who carry the burden of preserving this endangered democracy. Yes, it is understandable that the American moviegoer expects to be entertained; what has been lost since the Hollywood Renaissance circa 1960 – 1980 is the idea that we are to entertain the possibility that what we’ve witnessed could possibly be a commentary on life beyond celluloid. In order to do so, consider The Village’s symbolic representation of what is happening in our culture.


In the case of The Village, the symbolism is hardly buried in the visual text. The plot is the most obvious device in Shyamalan’s film; a story about an extremely conservative society which has been paralyzed by the fear of what lurks beyond its borders. The society within the village adheres to strict, ritualistic guidelines which assure the citizens that the borders will not be breeched by the enemy. If it does not sound plausible that Shyamalan’s intention was to comment on the impact of terrorist threat, consider the color pallet of the film. When the villagers must travel near or beyond the border of their settlement, they are instructed to wear yellow robes. The characters call yellow the “safe color.” Yet when wearing the yellow hoods, the characters approach the travel situation with heightened caution and trepidation. The villagers recognize the color red as the “bad color.” The color represents the creatures that live in the woods beyond the border of the village. The director contrived the color pallet as a means of tapping the audience on the shoulder and saying, “Ever hear of the Homeland Security Advisory System?” According to the system, when the threat level is at yellow, the level is elevated; there is a significant risk of terrorist attack. When the color coded system reaches red, travel – particularly foreign travel – is strongly discouraged. It is equally difficult not to wonder if the fact that the village’s leader, a man named Walker, who by the way has two daughters, is a tongue in cheek reference to America’s beloved W. And if so, this is where Shyamalan achieves total greatness.


Much of the American public who scoffed at Shyamalan’s film did so because the plausibility of Shyamalan’s ridiculous plot seemed preposterous. Yet, this is the America we live in. This is the America we’ve become since 9/11. So the question is this: if the average American refused to buy what Shyamalan was selling, how did a man like George W. Bush get elected twice? How is it that America responds to the Homeland Security Advisory System without so much as a huge WTF? And perhaps this is what really pissed the audience off. The joke was on them. Yet, Hollywood cashed in at the box office with two other low budget/high grossing successes with social commentary just as blatant as Shyamalan’s movie, the first of which was much more easily accepted and embraced by the same public who lambasted The Village.

Matt Reeve’s Cloverfield faired well at the box office. The cross over action adventure/sci-fi/horror film garnered high praises at the theater and impressive DVD sales after the theatrical run. How can this be accounted for? For one, it did not premiere until 2008. At this point, George Bush’s approval rating had gone down the tubes and public opinion about the lingering war in Iraq had shifted from blind patriotism to outspoken disapproval. Cloverfield fed off the changing tide of the public’s dissatisfaction. The commentary in Cloverfield was also buried deeper in the action of the film and the motivation of the movie’s gargantuan villain. The first report of the creature’s attack was of an oil rig being overturned in New York’s harbor: subtle commentary there. Next, the monster goes on to decapitate the Statue of Liberty, a mammoth symbol of America’s democracy. When the military are brought in to destroy the enemy, the battle is much more difficult that one would anticipate. A conventional barrage of aggressive military action was not enough to defeat what seemed to be an enemy that could easily be destroyed in spite of the massive threat it posed to America’s most weary city. It is also conceivable, given the disaster in New Orleans, that the nation’s military was spread too thin due to other conflicts. After all, the last thing the American Military could imagine being deployed for would be an unforeseeable disaster on American soil. In addition to the plot devices Reeves’ employed to tell his story, there is the unmistakable style in which the story was told.

The film’s first person narrative through the single video camera of a stander-by insinuates that perhaps the only truth behind a story can be told by the protagonists caught in the disaster. Government reports on the handling of the New Orleans disaster were greatly disputed by the residents who lived through the event. Surprisingly, especially after audiences’ negative reaction to Shyamalan’s twist ending, audiences were much more accepting of Reeves’ open ended conclusion. Reeves offered no resolution to the problem. The audience is led to believe that there is no salvation for the characters that they came to care for during the course of the film. And for the most part, audiences were fine with it. And why shouldn’t they have been? The conflict America is currently in the midst of has no ready resolution in sight. Perhaps the one thing that is shocking about the audience’s reaction to a film makers’ commentary is the mixed, if not mostly negative reaction to Frank Darabont’s The Mist, another film which chronicles an unexplainable disaster brought upon by mysterious creatures from another dimension.

Frank Darabont took Stephen King’s short story, The Mist, and beefed it up into what one could arguably identify as a two hour promotional reel for Hilary Clinton as president. One major theme that the movie touches upon is the failure of men to lead stunned civilians through an unprecedented disaster. Women are the true leaders and innovators in the film. Much like Shaymalan’s picture, The Mist was criticized for its plausibility. Is it really possible for human beings living in an age where technology is so advanced that weaponry beyond our wildest speculations could be left so helpless? Could they really be so clueless as to fail to find a means of rescue for themselves? If you find this hard to believe, again, I direct your attention to the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. In addition to this, Darabont paints a disturbing picture of how the far fanatical right wing moral majority are perhaps the greatest threat to democracy and civil liberty than any terrorist attack.

Marcia Gay Harden’s portrayal of the character Mrs. Carmody riveted theater goers into screaming at the silver screen. Her anti-climactic demise brought forth a burst of cheers from the audience I was sitting with during the second week of the movie’s theatrical run. And I’m sure that some of those spectators voted some of the same people into office that Pat Robinson funded. Darabont dared to do the same trick Shaymalan used in The Village: remove the audience enough from reality as a means of forcing them to confront a political issue they would typically support and make them see the folly in the character’s motivation. Darabont did this brilliantly. But he didn’t stop there. His criticism of the far left liberals was equally scorching. Bad decision after bad decision by Mrs. Carmody’s adversaries resulted in the protagonists finding themselves in the same dire situation in spite of their good intentions and liberal positions. And by the time the film reaches its remarkably shocking conclusion (which I will not spoil, but will say that it is easily the ballsiest, jaw dropping conclusion that I’ve seen to a film since the 1970s) the liberal party find themselves in what is an equally, if not more discombobulated state than their conservative counterparts. Interestingly enough, the final film in this analysis does something that its predecessors did not do as effectively; it presents the position of the conservative viewpoint and dares the viewer to consider the merit in conservative thinking, and allows the viewer to decide if the middle of the road is perhaps the safest place to be. Another film that challenges the viewer to take the mid-road perspective fared far better at the box office than The Mist, and won an Academy Award.

Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Night touches on a controversial topic. Nolan’s film doesn’t question the Patriot Act and its ramifications; it asks the viewer to question the ethics of the Patriot Act. Gotham City is besieged by a terrorist named The Joker. The Joker threatens to kill innocent citizens everyday until the masked super-vigilante turns himself in. Unable to risk exposure, Batman presses on in pursuit of The Joker. At one point, in attempt to protect the citizens of Gotham City, Batman uses technology which enables him to locate an individual by tracing the location of all the cell phones in the city. This is a gross violation of civil liberty, yet, it assists Mr. Wayne in finding The Joker and keeping Gotham City safe. Obviously, many liberals have watched and loved this movie. Though they may criticize George W. Bush and his tactics in combating terrorism, I’m sure they cheered Batman on as he captured his foe. And this is what good art should do; make the viewer question their own code of ethics and whether or not they actually understand what it is they love or hate about their respective parties, and whether or not they should be so easily partial because of party lines. Many of the same liberals who lashed out at conservatives for voting based on what left wingers would call non-issues, and many of those same liberals are one issue voters, and for most of them, their one issue is that they hated George W. Bush.

The most important thing art in the early twenty-first century can do is make us question everything. It is easy to get caught up in what appears to be symbolic propaganda, but many times when an artist appears to be supporting an issue, their true intention is to get people thinking about the issue, not to convince them to wear the issue as a mantle. In any case, twenty-first century Hollywood appears to be in the midst of a new renaissance. The bold social commentary of recent films has made a successful cross-over from the small indie-scene to the mainstream blockbusters, and this is a good thing. Many other mainstream movies are addressing issues with the intent of making the viewer think: Watchmen, though originally created to comment of the cold war fears of the 1980’s, touches upon a great deal of modern cultural and political concerns… but that my friends is its own essay, coming soon. If you do not have a tendency to watch films closely, I suggest you strive to see beyond the barrier of plot and mechanics. Even the film Orphan slipped a tongue-in-cheek cultural joke. When the couple is unable to bear a third child, they refuse to stop trying and eventually adopt a child. The third child seems to be the one who tipped the scales of balance in their home: the couples’ names are John and Kate. Films are fun and entertaining, but the modern film seems to want to re-introduce the notion that they can be intellectually stimulating as well, and that being intellectually stimulated is fun. And it is. And please understand, the issue that endangers our democracy is not the solitary issue that threatens us, it is America’s irresponsibility of not thinking outside the box which is the most horrific threat.

5/27/09

Post-Post Modernism in the Public Consciousness: Part 1 - A Hatchet Piece

In the true spirit of the Post-Post Modernists, I present for your reading pleasure, a redux of a previous rant...

For lack of a better term, contemporary critics have begun to call post-9/11 art Post-Post Modernism. The more I think about it, the less it bothers me. After all, it was the Post Modernists who predicted that culture would endlessly recycle itself and great artists who produced great works of art would be forgotten. They couldn’t have been more accurate. The 1970’s brought forth a plethora of iconic images from the wild 1950’s; Grease was the word, Happy Days dialogue spilled over into the vernacular, and pre-Star Wars George Lucas had a hit with American Graffiti. When the eighties rolled around, tie dies were once again in fashion and there were two Woodstock revivals. The nineties gave album oriented rock its last hoorah while slackers in bell bottoms swarmed the traveling music festivals. The very beginning of the twenty-first century found itself sounding more like 1981 than 2001, and then the unthinkable happened. Pop culture logic would solemnly swear that 9/11 marks the beginning of a new artistic period. After all, if the rapid change in technology and World War I contributed to the Modernist movement, and the atom bomb ushered in a less optimistic period than its predecessor, then contemporary critics are right on the money. But what about that awful name: Post-Post Modernism. It sounds comical, uninspired, even lazy. Could there be a better moniker for a period that is basically Modernism 2.0? If Post-Modernism saw pieces of culture trickling back into the public consciousness, what would the Post-Modernists have to say about Hollywood’s recent trend of raping classic films, compromising their dignities by re-scribbling a screenplay and handing it to an incompetent director? Doesn’t it make sense that we would recycle the name of the era itself? I believe it does. So what, right? Not that all PPM art is artistically compromised, but there is a huge chunk of it that certainly is, and nowhere is it more prevalent than in the horror film genre. Every genre has its landmark achievement; you can’t mention the words “gangster movie” without The Godfather coming to mind. Gone with the Wind is the cookie cutter for epic drama. It’s a Wonderful Life contributed more isms to the Holiday Blockbuster than any other film of its kind. And then there’s the horror genre, and those of you who know me well know just where I’m going with this. Anyone could hear Michael Bay tripping over the rights to The Amityville Horror and Friday the 13th a mile away, but that comes with the territory. However, it is sacrilege that his first remake cha-ching was a hideous re-imagining of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and Richard P. Rubenstine’s production team taking on a remake of George A. Romero’s Dawn of the Dead is sickening. Those of us who love these films knew damn well that the unthinkable would happen sooner or later, and it did. And Hollywood would be hard pressed to find a bigger jackass to defile the sacred. Yes, I am referring to Rob Zombie’s Halloween. Go ahead, yawn, have yourself a stretch, and when you’re good and ready, listen up.

Rob Zombie re-defines Halloween – that is undisputable. Unfortunately, this redefinition is a direct result of Zombie’s incompetence as a writer and director. Zombie’s re-imagining/prequel of John Carpenter’s 1978 masterpiece is yet another Hollywood victory in the attempt to convert art into eye candy for the attention spanless generation. Gone is the subtle social commentary; it is replaced with cheap cliché’ and conventions of shock cinema, only it isn’t all that shocking. Michael Myers has been reduced to the product of trailer trash rather than the evil sprout sprung from the seed of suburban complacency. And this is where Zombie’s deficiencies are most evident.

The opening of the original Halloween lasted all but five minutes: a mobile subjective camera shot, then a brief switch in perspective as a crane slowly pulled back to reveal what seemed to be the fully functional Myers family, in an uncomfortably long shot, where everything appeared to be normal with the exception of the bloody knife in six-year-old Michael’s hand. Enough said. But not for Zombie. Instead he gives the audience, who he obviously assumes is as ignorant as he is, almost forty minutes of exposition in an attempt to create a mythology for the Myers character. Michael’s step-dad is a meanie, his mommy is a pole dancer, and his sister is a whore. Somehow, Zombie felt this necessary to build Michael’s character. And at what point are we supposed to fear Michael? Certainly not when he brutally murders a school bully. Any human being that has been subjected to any kind of cruelty from peers, which is basically all of us, is going to identify with little Mikey sympathetically. The moment the audience starts rooting for the serial killer, the scares are gone. It becomes the same cheap slasher dung that plagued the eighties.

Judging by its thirty million dollar opening weekend, all of this is good. After all, Carpenter provoked his audience to look closely at the Myers clan and decipher the evil for themselves. But movie savior Rob Zombie has the solution in all of its vulgar glory laid out for his audience. Forget about the fact that the original Myers sprung from middle class America, far too concerned with production and consumption to recognize the result of person to person deprivation, a true demon of the Post-Modern era, which could be all the more relevant now in the age of the internet and i-phone than it was in 1978. This is where Zombie completely failed. Our culture may have actually been ready for a re-telling of the Myers story. Too bad Rob had to re-imagine it for us.

It’s a shame Rob couldn’t make up his mind whether Myers was white trash or the boogeyman. It’s also a shame that he took a character like Sam Loomis, so competently portrayed by the legendary Donald Pleasance, and turned him into a blubbering wimp. And as for Laurie’s friends, Annie and Lynda – who cares at this point. Slice ‘em up and get on with it. What’s the point of character development in a movie that is too over-developed for its own good? This deprived generation will never identify with Lynda and her overuse of “totally,” or Annie’s preoccupation with her hair in spite of the fact that she was wearing a man’s shirt and no pants. So what is the point of any of it? A thirty million dollar opening weekend. And that’s it.

Zombie and producer Malek Akkad new very well they had the attention of two generations: the first being those of us who loved and cherished this film as that rare achievement where good film making transcended the restraints of genre, and the second being the generation that grew up hearing about it from parents and older relatives. Perusing the message boards, I found that one defender of this film boldly stated that it was “never meant to be as good at the original.” I guess Zombie was shooting for the eighties “New Coke!” attitude. Remember how bad that sucked? Remember how quick “Coke Classic” took its place? Retracing the footsteps of Coca-Cola’s failure, Rob Zombie birthed a product that was all hype, and his taste-budless minions sucked it right down with the “new must mean better” mentality that plagues their generation. Other defenders challenged the naysayers to not compare the two films. Since when is comparing products a bad idea for consumers? If Zombie’s crowd doesn’t want his films being compared to classics he can’t possibly hope to improve, maybe he shouldn’t remake them. Maybe he should go back to directing cartoonish MTV versions of Texas Chainsaw Massacre and title them House of a Thousand Whatevers. Zombie is a tool. Really. A tool in the hands of a depraved Hollywood out of original ideas for anything besides making a couple million bucks.
Now that the unthinkable has happened, it is safe to say that the critics who have knighted this era Post-Post Modernism are perhaps more intuitive that I originally gave them credit for. But this is only the dark side of the Post-Post Modern age of horror. There is light at the end of the tunnel. With the same zeal that independent filmmakers impressed their indelible stamp of socially aware film making, there are directors attempting to do the same by recycling the mentality only, and not the art. Films like Cloverfield, The Mist, and M. Night Shalman’s The Village expose the failures of the Bush-Cheney era with genuine intelligence and unflinching attitude. And this is where the real art of the Post-Post Modern era finds its significance. Whichever genre you prefer, watch closely. Look beyond the plot. Revel in the filmmaker’s underlying commentary, and embrace Post-Post Modernism for what it accurately is.